LawAdvisor Directory
308 robbins watson lr

Christine Smyth

Partner at Robbins Watson Solicitors

20 years PQE
Gold Coast, QLD, AU
    308 robbins watson lr

    WILLS AND UNDUE INFLUENCE

    Age brings fragility and vulnerability.  Life comes full circle – once we were carers for our children, then as we age they often become our carers for us.  In these years of fragility, our affections, sentiment and gratitude can soften a once hardened view point.   These changes in our attit...
    308 robbins watson lr

    WILLS AND UNDUE INFLUENCE

    Age brings fragility and vulnerability.  Life comes full circle – once we were carers for our children, then as we age they often become our carers for us.  In these years of fragility, our affections, sentiment and gratitude can soften a once hardened view point.   These changes in our attit...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Photo 1447023029226 ef8f6b52e3ea

    WHAT MAKES AN EXPERT?

    10,000 hours of dedicated concentrated practice in your chosen field is identified in the book Outliers[1] as being what it takes to become an expert in your area of specialisation.  In working terms, that equates with 10 years of concentrated experience at 20 hours a week, or 5 years of concentr...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    Family Law & Disability - what does that have to do with Estate Pla...

    Many years ago, one of my infant relatives suffered a catastrophic brain injury. When he received his compensation award, we turned our minds to his estate planning needs. Hence, I acted in one of the very first successful Statutory Will applications in Qld at the time. The introduction of the ND...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    Cost of a self-made will & Intestacy?

    Salier v Watson [2014] NSWSC 237How often do you find clients balk at the cost of estate planning? In this matter I acted on behalf of the successful first defendant involving an application for construction of a self-made will where his grandfather gifted two units E$6 million, one on trust to h...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    DIVORCE BY THIRD PARTY - AN ESTATE PLANNING ISSUE

    In the March edition of the STEP Journal I discuss how a third party can seek a divorce on behalf of an incapacitated adult. Such an application can have wide ranging estate planning consequences.If you would like to know more here is a link to my article :-https://www.robbinswatson.com.au/sites/...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    DVD Will Probated

    Sadly another suicide has resulted in a further version of an electronic will being probated, in this instance it was a will recorded to DVD. In Mellino v Wnuk & Orsthe Queensland Supreme Court was asked to determine if a DVD made by the deceased, immediately prior to his suicide, was his last wi...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    PLEASE LEAVE THE ROOM

    We act for many aged clients, sometimes they have mobility issues, sometimes they can’t drive, and sometimes they simply need support. So it is no surprise when they arrive for appointments accompanied by friends and/or relatives. While we are pleased that they have that support, it can be proble...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    FUNERAL EXPENSES - WHAT IS REASONABLE?

    I once had a client who wanted a mausoleum to house his body on his death and to memorialise his life. Of course I was obligated to advise that without a specific sum allocated for this purpose the estate was only liable for reasonable funeral costs. Mausoleums are expensive and so as part of his...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Default cover small

    Significant Super Decision – Duty of a PR to raise a claim upon sup...

    McIntosh v McIntosh [2014] QSC 99. This decision provides jurisprudence for an issue which I have for some time been concerned. That is ” how should the legal personal representative of a deceased person deal with the entitlement to payment of the deceased person's superannuation upon death.” The...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Aaeaaqaaaaaaaaohaaaajdzjn2i5ntbhlwnhmdytngq1ns1hmje3lwvkntnhzjbizmqxzg

    Pushing up Daisies - composting not cremating?

    Are we ready for composting our loved ones as a final act of giving back or is it just too confronting? The attached article advocates the development in the US of Compost Burials. That is, instead of traditional burials, donating  human bodies for composting.  Proponents of the concept argue tha...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Wills published on the internet.

    It is a common misconception that a will is a private document. In an era where our lives are more public than ever, it is anomaly that many clients consider the will of a deceased to be a private document, only for the eyes of a few.  On the contrary, it is one of the deceased's last public stat...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Wills published on the internet.

    It is a common misconception that a will is a private document. In an era where our lives are more public than ever, it is anomaly that many clients consider the will of a deceased to be a private document, only for the eyes of a few.  On the contrary, it is one of the deceased's last public stat...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Cost v. Value - $27,000.00 is a lot of money

    All too often people focus on the cost of a service without realising the value of the service, and so it is with legal services. The availability of information on the internet tends to lull people into thinking that the use of legal services is either expensive or unnecessary when the informati...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Cost v. Value - $27,000.00 is a lot of money

    All too often people focus on the cost of a service without realising the value of the service, and so it is with legal services. The availability of information on the internet tends to lull people into thinking that the use of legal services is either expensive or unnecessary when the informati...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Death With Dignity Law - California

    "I have a terminal Illnes, I'm going to die a long painful death and I don't want my family put through that kind of trauma. So I'm getting on a plane at the end of the week to go overseas so I can euthanaise myself." These were my instructions from a dying client, in my office to finalise affair...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Death With Dignity Law - California

    "I have a terminal Illnes, I'm going to die a long painful death and I don't want my family put through that kind of trauma. So I'm getting on a plane at the end of the week to go overseas so I can euthanaise myself." These were my instructions from a dying client, in my office to finalise affair...
    308 robbins watson lr

    TOMBSTONE TECHNOLOGY

    Modern life is peripatetic.  We no longer live and work in the one community all of our lives. Life gets busy, we lose touch with people we once knew and loved.  Then we discover some pass, and in our quieter moments we reflect and often seek to say our final goodbyes.  Utilising technology, the ...
    308 robbins watson lr

    TOMBSTONE TECHNOLOGY

    Modern life is peripatetic.  We no longer live and work in the one community all of our lives. Life gets busy, we lose touch with people we once knew and loved.  Then we discover some pass, and in our quieter moments we reflect and often seek to say our final goodbyes.  Utilising technology, the ...
    308 robbins watson lr

    Successful Succession a Success!

    Katerina Peiros and I are chuffed our Australian Tax Institute column – Successful Succession has been so well received it will move from a quarterly publication to bi-monthly.  Thank you to the team at Australian Tax Institute  for sharing our vision and your support for our column.  
    308 robbins watson lr

    Successful Succession a Success!

    Katerina Peiros and I are chuffed our Australian Tax Institute column – Successful Succession has been so well received it will move from a quarterly publication to bi-monthly.  Thank you to the team at Australian Tax Institute  for sharing our vision and your support for our column.  
    308 robbins watson lr

    ELDER ABUSE - “The afternoon knows what the morning never suspected.”

    When we think of domestic violence, often it is in the context of couple relationships.  However, there are other forms and elder abuse is one which is an increasing shame in our community.  The Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence has heard that 92 per cent of abuse of the elderly is ...
    308 robbins watson lr

    ELDER ABUSE - “The afternoon knows what the morning never suspected.”

    When we think of domestic violence, often it is in the context of couple relationships.  However, there are other forms and elder abuse is one which is an increasing shame in our community.  The Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence has heard that 92 per cent of abuse of the elderly is ...
    308 robbins watson lr

    A free lunch? Dangers of wills drawn by unqualified people.

    How many times have you asked: Why should I pay  when I can get it for free? In this regard  cases such as  Re Maria Elizabeth Rudd; ex parte Prince [2015] WASC 107 provide insight as to what often occurs when price alone drives the decision. The matter involved an informal will prepared by a wel...
    308 robbins watson lr

    A free lunch? Dangers of wills drawn by unqualified people.

    How many times have you asked: Why should I pay  when I can get it for free? In this regard  cases such as  Re Maria Elizabeth Rudd; ex parte Prince [2015] WASC 107 provide insight as to what often occurs when price alone drives the decision. The matter involved an informal will prepared by a wel...
    308 robbins watson lr
    Christine Smyth agreed with Val Antoff 's answer on Executor duties
    almost 9 years ago

    This means that you have been named by the maker of the will as the person appointed to carry out the directions of the will.

    The role of the executor is time consuming and very important. I have listed some of your duties and responsibilities as an executor:

    • Disposal of the body of the deceased
    • Pay debts of the estate - secured and unsecured liabilities
    • Distribution of the estate assets
    • Obtain the last will of the deceased and review its contents
    • Make arrangements for the funeral and pay funeral expenses
    • Inform the beneficiaries of the will of their entitlements and give them a copy of the will
    • Arrange for the care of the deceased’s pets
    • Place a notice in a newspaper about the death of the testator
    • Hold initial interview with beneficiaries
    • Inspect properties and take action to secure assets by changing locks on property and liaising with the relevant insurance companies
    • Contact financial institutions and determine holdings and liabilities
    • Advertise for creditors of the estate
    • Obtain the deceased’s death certificate
    • Obtain proof of identity of all beneficiaries
    • Obtain financial and accounting advice
    • Attend to searches of Australian share registries
    • Locate certificates of title
    • Compile a complete list of estate assets and liabilities
    • Apply for and obtain Grant of Probate
    • Bring in money from financial institutions
    • Sell real estate and other assets
    • Open an interest bearing account in the name of the estate
    • Invest funds in an interest bearing account
    • File Income tax returns up to the date of death
    • Finalise the deceased’s Centrelink or Department of Veterans Affairs pensions and entitlements up to date of death
    • Inform Medicare
    • Arrange transfer of or finalise final accounts for telephone, electricity, gas, and other relevant services
    • Finalise and process final refund of contributions to medical insurance funds
    • Advise relevant financial institutions to guard against unauthorised use of bank accounts
    • Establish Trusts if beneficiaries are under 18 years of age, mentally incapable, or if there are specific instructions in the will
    • Provide regular updates to beneficiaries
    • Work with beneficiaries to try to resolve disputes
    • Prepare legal defence to claims made against the estate
    • Confirm entitlements with beneficiaries
    • Lodge final estate tax return
    • Prepare statements of account.

    Most likely, you would have been also appointed as a trustee under the will. The duties, powers and rights of trustees in Western Australia which I have listed next are governed by TheTrustee Act 1962(WA).


    • Duty to preserve and invest trust property
    • Duty to obey the terms of the Will
    • Duty to keep accounts and supply information
    • Duty to act impartially
    • Duty to pay correct beneficiaries
    • Power to delegate
    • Power of sale
    • Powers of management
    • Right to seek advice and directions of the court
    • Right of reimbursement and indemnity

    A year or more is not an unusual time for some estates to be completely administered.The good news is that if you are discouraged by the daunting list of tasks, duties and responsibilities that come with your role as an executor you can retain a lawyer to assist you. The cost for such services will be covered from the assets of the estate.You are not bound to accept the office and may renounce (reject) the executorship role.

    308 robbins watson lr
    Christine Smyth agreed with Val Antoff 's answer on Online will creation
    almost 9 years ago

    I don't see any obstacles for a free service like this to be offered in Australia. There are already several paid online will assembly sites.


    It is important to keep in mind that there are several aspects to estate planning and the drafting of the will is done after a thorough investigation by a lawyer of the client's circumstances. The question that remains to be answered is if the logic of such an investigation can be built into an online wills service.


    I have included an example of the investigation process I undertake in the preparation of a client's estate plan.


    An important step in the estate planning process is to ascertain what assets and liabilities form part of the client's estate. For example, some jointly owned assets or assets held in a trust cannot be gifted in a will.

    Below is a chart with assets commonly owned by a testator.



    One of the most important tasks for a lawyer advising on your will and estate plan is to identify key risks.

    Examples include:

    • Protecting your estate assets in case of a financial failure
    • Ensuring that gifts to spendthrift beneficiaries are protected from creditors
    • Life risk
    • Marriage or relationshipbreakdown risk - a binding financial agreement may be suitable
    • Taxation issues
    • Family business retention

    Below is a chart which gives examples of some of the risks and the potentially affected persons.


    308 robbins watson lr
    Christine Smyth agreed with Rhys Ryan 's answer on Trust
    almost 9 years ago

    A trust is an arrangement where one person or organisation (the trustee) holds assets (the trust property) on behalf of another person (the beneficiary). Trusts can be established for a number of reasons such as tax planning, providing for children or charitable causes.

    The requirements for setting up a trust depend on the type of trust you want to establish and its purpose. To create any trust in Queensland, you will need to:

    • select a trustee who will agree to be responsible for administering the trust in accordance with the terms of the trust deed;
    • have a lawyer prepare a trust deed (a legal document that sets out the rules for establishing and operating the trust) that is to be signed by the trustee;
    • give the assets (even if only a nominal amount) to the trustee;
    • pay stamp duty to the Office of State Revenue if a trust is created over ‘dutiable property’, as that term is defined in the Duties Act 2001 (Qld); and
    • apply for an ABN and TFN for the trust online via the Australian Business Register or through a lawyer or accountant.

    You should also be aware of additional legal requirements that apply to particular types of trusts. For example: a trust used to run a business must be registered for GST if annual turnover is $75,000 or more; a trust used to run a self-managed super fund must ensure it complies with the relevant superannuation and taxation laws that apply to it; and charitable trusts are subject to special laws and may be eligible for tax exemptions.

    You should speak to a lawyer if you want to set up a trust in Queensland. By pressing the "Take Action" button - which opens late July - LawAdvisor can help you search for experienced lawyers and obtain fee proposals for their services.